- Don't look back
- Is support for OSS optional in your business?
- Nokia N810 Tablet + WiMax
- Vendors need to right-size their products
- Dolphins Invade Sun Campus!
- State of Open Source
- MySQL Workbench: open source data modeling
- Comments on The 451 Group's Database Report & Red Hat's 4Q revenue
- Kaplan: Guiding open source in IT
- Can the transportation market teach us anything about the software market?
July 15, 2006 | Comments: (0)
Why is good software harder to find than good music?
A good friend from Stanford, Lincoln Davies, turned me on to Clap Your Hands Say Yeah today, and I've been listening ever since. What a great sound. If you're into Radiohead, The Shins, White Stripes, etc. (as I am), you'll probably really like their sound.
I've used Pandora before for this same purpose - music discovery - and it works much the same as Lincoln's informal advice. (Except Pandora doesn't abuse my basketball prowess while advising on music.)
Why doesn't open source work the same? You like Plone? You'll really like SugarCRM (or whatever), and here's why. Nothing like that exists (of which I'm aware) today in open source. Ohioh (weak name) aims to help us discover the relative strength of a project, and Krugle helps you find great code in the first place, but there are no matching engines (again, of which I'm aware) to coordinate needs and preferences with open source software.
I suppose this is what SIs and analysts do (and I know some do it quite well), but surely there's a first-try method available somewhere? Or should be?
The record labels - bless 'em! - perform the music selection and promotion process reasonably well. Surely a software analog is ready to be born....
Posted by Matt Asay on July 15, 2006 05:21 PM
RATE THIS ARTICLE:
-

- COMMENTS
I get the point that you are trying to make but what you are missing is that the majority of the music that you are mentioning all comes from major labels--which you could equate to proprietary vendors recommending other proprietary vendors--there is a much larger universe out there. Pandora will do its best but from my experience (tried it again today) it doesn't find indie bands...which means they recommend a BigCo label.
But I do agree that there should be some kind of cross-reference library--ie. you want a Java SOAP app so choose Tomcat+Spring+Xfire. Ohloh is sorta interesting, but consider that its pulling a great deal of data from sourceforge.net and you have to take the results with a grain of salt (FYI-I submitted Alfresco for you:)
The relevant information all lies within the community--the crew who write apps and create their own stacks. It seems like an opportunity for a company like SpikeSource or SourceLabs who want to push standardized stacks, despite the realization that everyone runs a different infrastructure.
Posted by: Dave Rosenberg at July 16, 2006 04:31 PMThe biggest problem with the lack of open source "human" utilities (media players, SOAP programs, etc.) is because oepn source developers mainly program for themselves, and for the most part, these developers are only intrested in computers. Simply put, they are a android AI trapped in a human body, sort of speak. They find most things we use for entertainment to be of little to no value to them, and only desire to progressively program more development tools and other high-end mathmatical software than write software for the average Joe Shmoe, mainly because the things that Joe Shmoe wants bore them. Open source developers mostly behave like the Borg from Star Trek. But seriously, would you work on something that bored you?
Posted by: Segin at July 17, 2006 10:22 PM
- Get Started
- Port 25 Blogs
- OSS News
- Join a Project
{Open Source} Heroes Happen Here
Start today and order your own Hero Hack Pack – which includes Getting Started with Open Source, Windows Server 2008 and Visual Studio 2008 Trial. Each pack is a chance to win a free pass to OSCON 2008.
TOP STORIES
ADDITIONAL RESOURCES

- Do you have the power to resolve technical issues with one call?
- Take control of your content- leverage Microsoft SharePoint
- Keeping the E-Mail Flowing

- SGI Adaptive Data Warehouse: Building a High-End Oracle Data Warehouse
- Five Steps to Secure Outsourced Application Development
- Global Shared Memory: Performance and Productivity Breakthroughs








