- Don't look back
- Is support for OSS optional in your business?
- Nokia N810 Tablet + WiMax
- Vendors need to right-size their products
- Dolphins Invade Sun Campus!
- State of Open Source
- MySQL Workbench: open source data modeling
- Comments on The 451 Group's Database Report & Red Hat's 4Q revenue
- Kaplan: Guiding open source in IT
- Can the transportation market teach us anything about the software market?
December 17, 2006 | Comments: (0)
Open source: Reality bites?
I'm reading an exceptional biography of William James, and came across this passage from a philosopher he was reading (i.e., Sydney Smith, Elementary Sketches of Moral Philosophy)
A great philosopher may sit in his study and deny the existence of matter: but if he takes a walk in the street he must take care to leave his theory behind him....Indeed. I love to talk with open source developers who try their hand at the business side of open source. Invariably, many of their cherished notions of "freedom" and "fairness" are changed by the necessity of earning a dime.Pyrro said that there was no such thing as pain; and he saw no proof that there were such things as carts, and wagons; and he refused to get out of their way: but Pyrro had, fortunately for him, three or four stout slaves, who followed their master, without following his doctrine; and whenever they saw one of these ideal machines approaching, took him up by the arms and legs, and without attempting to controvert his arguments, put him down in a place of safety.
We may believe anything for a moment, but we shall soon be lashed out of our impertinences by hard and stubborn realities. (4, 7)
It's nice to have ideals. It's better to temper them with reality. Fortunately, oft times the fiercest of ideals weds nicely with reality. I find this true of Eben Moglen and the Free Software Foundation. It would be hard to find better capitalists anywhere....(And no, I'm absolutely not kidding.)
Posted by Matt Asay on December 17, 2006 11:44 PM
RATE THIS ARTICLE:
-

- COMMENTS
This post is very enlightening. While speaking with the CEO of another development company here in Dallas, he stated, "Open Source people are a bunch of Socialist who want everyone to make the same amount of money."
This comment took me by surprise and I couldn't respond as I had wanted. I started thinking about MySQL, Red Hat, etc. and wondering how he can be so blind to the fact that the business models for some of the leading OS companies not only work, but work very well.
Thanks for the insight. I'll be much better prepared next time I hear a such nonsense coming from a "Microsoft Certified Partner in Denial".
Posted by: Brian H. at December 18, 2006 08:02 AMYou probably already know this piece by Bruce Perens
from http://www.gnuband.org/2005/02/16/capitalism-enthusiasts_should_go_for_open_source/
"The Emerging Economic Paradigm of Open Source by Bruce Perens: recommended! Open source and capitalism are really more similar than what you think.
It’s not immediately obvious how Open Source[1] works economically. Probably the worst consequence of this lack of understanding is that many people don’t understand how Open Source could be economically sustainable, and some may even feel that its potential negative effect upon the proprietary software industry is an overall economic detriment. Fortunately, if you look more deeply into the economic function of software in general, it’s easy to establish that Open Source is both sustainable and of tremendous benefit to the overall economy.
Open Source can be explained entirely within the context of conventional open-market economics. Indeed, it turns out that it has much stronger ties to the phenomenon of capitalism than you may have appreciated. "

- Get Started
- Port 25 Blogs
- OSS News
- Join a Project
{Open Source} Heroes Happen Here
Start today and order your own Hero Hack Pack – which includes Getting Started with Open Source, Windows Server 2008 and Visual Studio 2008 Trial. Each pack is a chance to win a free pass to OSCON 2008.
TOP STORIES
ADDITIONAL RESOURCES

- Remote Access: Maintain Security and Decrease the Burden on IT
- Beyond AntiVirus: Symantec Endpoint Protection
- What Every Enterprise Needs to Know About VDI

- Disaster Recovery in Minutes
- Protecting Microsoft(R) Applications
- Reduce Recovery Times and Tape Costs








