Free Newsletters

   All InfoWorld Newsletters
SMB IT | Curtis Franklin » REVIEW: Iomega StorCenter Pro 150d

March 12, 2007 | Comments: (0)

REVIEW: Iomega StorCenter Pro 150d

150d.jpg
Okay, I just spent a few days dissing my Iomega 500GB StorCenter shared network hard disk because it suddenly started flaking on me after about 8 months of use. That didn't daunt Iomega, however, which sought to reclaim my mindshare by getting us a hands-on period with their new 1TB StorCenter Pro 150d.

The gist of this new StorCenter is that its a full-fledged NAS, in fact a close sibling of the Windows Storage Server-based StorCenter 200d. The 150d includes an automatic hook to Active Directory, and brings you most of the 200d's functionality along with a terabyte of data storage for about $800 (though you can get a 2TB version for more bucks). This is done with fewer hardware options (though you still have the USB connector so you can back up to a REV drive, for example) and a management interface based on Linux.

The Active Directory integration intrigued me because Iomega made a big point out of the fact that this is brainless, even though the StorCenter Pro 150d is based on Linux firmware. So I sent the thing to Brian Chee at the ANCL Lab in Hawaii so he could plug it into the Fergenschmeir domain, which is InfoWorld's Microsoft-only test network.

Brian turned my scoffing into silence, however, after he confirmed most of what Iomega promised. While hooking to the AD server had a wrinkle because both the NAS and the AD server need to be within 5 minutes of each other, that got fixed quickly with a manual clock change.

After that, the Iomega found the network's DHCP server; it then joined the Fergenschmeir AD domain in a couple of minutes and setup a basic share in yet a minute or two more. All done, access accomplished. It took a little extra time to figure out how to setup an NFS share, which proved to be more involved than simply clicking the checkbox (Iomega has some work to do there). But after that was working, Brian was able to connect not just to Windows machines, but Macs and Linux boxes as well.

The whole thing is managed through a Web interface that works as well in Firefox as it does in IE. Most everything is accomplished via checkboxes. The interface goes through setup options, user access controls and disk health. User access goes through local users, local groups as well as users and groups culled from the AD server. You can get alerts via the Interface or via email.

150dweb.jpg

There's even a general backup utility for backing up the entire NAS to a CIF share. All these controls are there and certainly easier to use than many other interfaces. But if anything goes wrong, our experience is still that you'll need to know what you're doing to get it fixed.

Even so, Iomega has done a good job of balancing advanced capabilities with a need for KISS (keep it simple stupid). For example, the StorCenter supports jumbo frames, but the option isn't turned on by default because many switches still don't support it which is a headache that neophyte users don't need.

Flip side to that, tho. Iomega tried to make NTP a one-click option, but if your AD server isn't handling NTP then the checkbox just sits there non-functioning with no real explanation. Also don't like the fact that only one person can be in the management interface at a time and that any attempts to connect to it via a VPN connection died hard.

So is it easy or not? It is, as long as nothing goes wrong. Sticking the 150d into an small SMB network shouldn't give you any trouble based on our experience. Performance was solid and getting something besides a Windows machine to access it, while not brain-dead easy, also isn't rocket science, either. So far, we'd recommend it.

StorCenter Pro 150d
Iomega
Base price: $800
Pros: Real simple, real easy, real quiet, truly hot-swappable drives
Cons: One-person access to the management interface, needs more granularity in user permissions, no access to management interface via VPNs.

Posted by Oliver Rist on March 12, 2007 10:39 AM


RATE THIS ARTICLE:





 

  •  
  • COMMENTS




This unit is incredibly enticing. Most units, although 1TB, only allow 0,1 RAID which means that in RAID 1 (mirror mode) you can only get 500 Gigs.

This Iomega unit allows you get 750 Gigs in RAID 5 since it has 4 drives. More cost effective storage space.

It also features:

* Linux based OS
* Flexible user and group based security,
* Above average performance with respect to RAID, responsiveness, and transfer speeds.
* Gigabit ethernet as well as 802.11G wireless
* 2 USB ports to attach additional storage
* 4 drive bays to upgrade and replace drives
* RAID 5 !!. This is a prominent feature that sets it in a unique category among entry level NAS.
* A very well built enclosure. All metal, fairly thick at that, as well as very sturdy enclosure for the HD's that uses screws. Nothing plastic of flimsy here.

All very very good features for a NAS. The price is slightly higher than competitive products, but the added features are well worth it.

Wait a second? I sound like a i am in love for the first time...... It can't be this good....

The biggest drawback? It's a deal killer.

* BAD AND HORRIBLY DEFECTIVE SOFTWARE ****

The software running the unit itself is flawed. Your data may be intact on the drives itself, but the administration software running on the unit can, and quite often, does fail.

When it fails, you have very little options. There are some limited recovery options on the unit and Iomega tech support has limited solutions as well. If these do not solve the problem, you can send the unit back to Iomega, BUT LOSE ALL YOUR DATA.

They do offer in-house data retrieval services, but quotes have run from $2500 to $6800 dollars depending on the amount of data to be retrieved.

Opening the enclosure itself voids the warranty accordingly, and there is a little a layperson could do on their own.

The internal drives are IDE. This means that taking the drives out and hooking them up to a independent system requires a separate 4-Channel IDE RAID card that supports RAID 0,1,5 + JBOD.

The costs of fixing it yourself can become prohibitive.

The whole point of this product is:

1) Network Attached Storage. Multiple computers accessing the data at the same time.

2) Backup. This requires reliability and redundancy (RAID)

This product, although very well spec'd, cannot live up to it's purpose and will be a liability to anybody using it.

Avoid this product at all costs.

Posted by: Ed at December 6, 2007 05:20 AM

Technology White Papers

 

InfoWorld Technology Marketplace

» Technology White Papers Library

Technology White Papers by Topic

Technology White Papers E-mail Alert

Find out when the latest white paper is available:
 
 
» BUY A LINK NOW

Sponsored Technology Links