My posting 20 registrars control 90% of illicit domains, says Knujon last Monday drew quite a bit of approval, and also a criticism of KnujOn's report for being incomplete. A more complete report that includes the methodology, the statistics, and the names is now up at KnujOn's site.
Who are the 10 dirtiest domain registrars according to KnujOn? The list follows. For explanations, please refer back to the report page. Not surprisingly, the worst three registrars are in China. Number 4 is in Germany. Places 5 through 10 are held by U.S. registrars.
What would it take to clean these registrars up or shut them down?
- Xinnet Bei Gong Da Software
Area Building 2, Level 1, BDA Beijing 100176 China
Total Domains: 897,962
Reported Sites: 15,551 – 4th highest for site volume (each site is pulled from a spam email)
Proportion of Reported to Total: 1.7% - 4th
Raw Aggression: 1,644,986 - 1st (Total count of spam emails featuring domains at this registrar)
Proportional Aggression: 183.19 -3rd (meaning 183 spams for each domain they hold)
Overall Score: 3 – 1st, the “worst”
Inaccuracy Count: 10,383 2nd for inaccuracies (in the last 12 months)
Inaccuracy Rating: 1% (Typical inaccuracy percentage is 0.004%, anything higher than 0.5% is bad)
Trademark Factor: 1st (This is based on site content and scoring for trademarked brands) - BEIJINGNN
20/F, Block A, SP Tower, Tsinghua Science Park Building 8, No.1 Zhongguaneun East Road Haidian District, Beijing 100084 China
Total Domains: 303,801 Reported Sites: 10,083 -8th highest for site volume
Proportion of Reported to Total: 3.3% - 3rd
Raw Aggression: 857,688 - 2nd
Proportional Aggression: 282.31 - 2nd
Overall Score: 3.75 – 2nd
Inaccuracy Count: 6705 - 6th
Inaccuracy Rating: 2%
Trademark Factor: 5th - Todaynic
Rm 603-605 6B, Xihai Building No. 221 Renmin E. Road Zhuhai City, Guangdong Province 519000 China
Total Domains: 66,314
Reported Sites: 2,958 -13th highest for site volume
Proportion of Reported to Total: 4.5% - 2nd
Raw Aggression: 342,511 - 4th
Proportional Aggression: 516.5 - 1st
Overall Score: 5 – 3rd
Inaccuracy Count: 2260 – 8th
Inaccuracy Rating: 3%
Trademark Factor: 11th - Joker
Hansaallee 191-193 40549 Duesseldorf Germany
Total Domains: 636,431
Reported Sites: 9051 -9th highest for site volume
Proportion of Reported to Total: 1.42% - 7th
Raw Aggression: 487,727 - 3rd
Proportional Aggression: 76.63 - 4th
Overall Score: 5.75 – 4th
Inaccuracy Count: 7746 – 4th
Inaccuracy Rating: 1%
Trademark Factor: 27th - eNom, Inc.
15801 NE 24th St. Bellevue, WA 98008 USA
Total Domains: 11,040,841
Reported Sites: 47,007 sites - 1st
Proportion of Reported to Total: 0.42% - 11th
Raw Aggression: 317,677 instances or messages - 5th
Proportional Aggression: 2.9 - 9th
Overall Score: 6.5 – 5th
Inaccuracy Count: 8530 – 3rd
Inaccuracy Rating: 0.1%
Trademark Factor: 3rd - MONIKER
20 SW 27th Ave. Suite 201 Pompano Beach, Florida 33069
Total Domains: 2,725,240
Reported Sites: 30628 -2nd highest for site volume
Proportion of Reported to Total: 1.12% - 8th
Raw Aggression: 87,071 - 9th
Proportional Aggression: 3.19 - 8th
Overall Score: 6.75 – 6th
Inaccuracy Count: 11,680 – 1st
Inaccuracy Rating: 0.4%
Trademark Factor: 21st - Dynamic Dolphin
5023 W 120th Ave #233 Broomfield CO
Total Domains: 45,019
Reported Sites: 7,846 -10th highest for site volume
Proportion of Reported to Total: 17.42% - 1st
Raw Aggression: 23,825 - 16th
Proportional Aggression: 52.92 - 6th
Overall Score: 8.25 – 7th
Inaccuracy Count: 4744 – 6th
Inaccuracy Rating: 10%
Trademark Factor: 22nd - The Nameit Co/AITDOMAINS.COM
421 Maiden Lane Fayetteville, N.C. 28301
Total Domains: 155,474
Reported Sites: 2620 -16th highest for site volume
Proportion of Reported to Total: 1.68% - 5th
Raw Aggression: 103,786 - 7th
Proportional Aggression: 66.75 -5th
Overall Score: 8.25 – 8th
Inaccuracy Count: 1433 – 8th
Inaccuracy Rating: 1%
Trademark Factor: 45th 9. PDR - PDR
14525 SW Millikan #48732 Beaverton Oregon, 97005-2343
Total Domains: 1,751,224
Reported Sites: 13,025 - 6th highest for site volume
Proportion of Reported to Total: 0.74% - 9th
Raw Aggression: 45,319 – 13th
Proportional Aggression: 2.59 - 10th
Trademark Factor: 9.5 – 9th
Inaccuracy Count: 6986 – 5th
Inaccuracy Rating: 0.4%
Trademark Factor: 20th - Intercosmos/DIRECTNIC
650 Poydras Street, Suite 1150 New Orleans, Louisiana 70130
Total Domains: 1,125,148
Reported Sites: 4918 -11th highest for site volume
Proportion of Reported to Total: 0.43% - 10th
Raw Aggression: 50678 - 12th
Proportional Aggression: 4.504118569 - 7th
Overall Score: 10 – 10th
Inaccuracy Count: 868 – 12th
Inaccuracy Rating: 0.1%
Trademark Factor: 13th
Posted by Martin Heller on May 21, 2008 08:35 AM
